Samuel Taylor Coleridge described this as "A delicious poem." "Notes on The Temple and The Synagogue," in The Temple by George Herbert,
(Pickering: London, 1838). p. 356.
Criticism:
"George Herbert and Lady Mary Wroth: a root for 'The Flower'?" by R. E. Pritchard.
"Show and tell: George Herbert, Richard Sibbes, and communings with God." by Daniel W. Doerksen. Christianity and Literature, Wntr 2002 v51 i2 p175(17). [Works cited: "The Holdfast," "Clasping of Hands," "Assurance," "A true Hymne," "The Pearl," "The Crosse," "Coloss. 3.3," "The Flower," "Unkindnesse," "The Method," "Church-lock and key," "Praise (II)"]
Theological Dualism in the Poetry of George Herbert by Carolyn Elizabeth Woodruff. [Works discussed: The Flower, Affliction (I), Affliction (V), Banquet and Love (III).]
George Herbert's Poetry by Russell Fraser. [Poems cited: "Holy Scriptures I"; "The Pearl"; The Temple; "Paradise"; "Affliction"; "Home"; "The Collar"; "The Flower"; "Virtue"; "Providence"]
Artistic Interpretation: An altar cloth sometimes used at St. Andrew's, Bemerton created by Jane Lemon on the poem "The Flower." [Click for Bemerton Site, Art at Bemerton]
The Flower interpretation and analysis following is quoted "as is" from a University of Texas at Austin page no longer on the Internet:
Interchange 7 on
George Herbert
Herbert I
Carlo Savino:
In "The Flower", Herbert describes life as a garden, where we are each given
space as a flower to grow towards the sun (heaven). Some are allowed to
flourish while others wither and die. Herbert says that when ager comes to
him, he falls back and grows no more. However, immediately after, he writes:
"And now in age I bud again,
After so many deaths I live and write;
I once more smell the dew and rain,
And relish versing: O my onley night,
It cannot be
That I am he
On whom thy tempests fell at night."
After his inability to grow, and the fact that he succumbs to anger, Herbert is
given another chance at life. Is he trying to say that experience is found
only after pain? And who do you think that the 'tempests' are?
Carlo Savino:
whoops, I should have said, "...experience and growth are found...".
sorry about that.
Melanie Elizabeth Oxley:
As each man has sorrow, so will man have joy equal in magnitude. If experience
is a well, then it must expand and grow in depth in order to hold the new
volume. The tempests are simply those calamities that cause pain and sorrow .
Thus inducing growth. Even though a horrible storm will beat down a bud, it
will rise new again from the water it has drank.
Julie Lopez:
I think that he is saying that you grow form your experiences whether they be
bad or good. So don't stop living because something has caused you pain
because then you will die.
Carlo Savino:
Okay, Melanie, but why must man fail to develop (as a flower shrinks and dies,
in this poem) if he is overcome by anger? how does this make a man falter in
his growth?
Jason Lands:
I agree, Herbert is showing us that life is basically a circle of pleasure and
pain, good and bad. Kind of a feel good silver-lining around every cloud sort
of message.
Christopher O'Docharty:
Well, well, well. Even though I did not read this lovely poem, I found it
intriguing. I think basicly he spent too long feeling sorry for himself for
all of themistakes and problems he may have had. It's probably safe to say
that he finally decided to get on with his life and do what heloves
most-writing.
Higinio Maycotte:
Carlo
Perhaps because when you make a mistake you are beaten down, only to learn from
that experience and grow again.
Jason Lands:
And being able to overcome your weaknesses makes you less of a man.
Carlo Savino:
And why does herbert say that some men forfeit thier chance at paradise throug
hubris? shouldn't every man, regardless of pride, be allowed a chance to sit
next to god?
Jason Lands:
not being able. Sorry
Melanie Elizabeth Oxley:
Anger is an unproductive, irrational response. It is almost an instinctual,
primal-like regression. This regression is represented by a shrinking flower,
he falters in his growth because he has not learned a positive way to overcome
his frustrations.
Julie Lopez:
I also think that he is saying that God gave us the ablity to overcome our
grief. Therefore, you grow from it.
Bun Sentoso:
I agree with Jason, it seems taht Herbert is trying to conclude human's life in
this one poem. First it grows, leaving its parents, then it starts to see the
world, tastes sin which make it feel as if it's in heaven. At the end, 'in age'
it realizes all his mistakes and returns to God.
Jason Lands:
Maybe Herbert believes overcoming your grief is the test God has set for us to
enter into his kingdom. It would fit into his analogy of growing towards
heaven and having your growth stunted when you fail
Higinio Maycotte:
Melanie,
I don't agree that anger is unproductive, irrational at times, yes. When I get
angry it often motivates me to get on with my life and take, what ever
experience that has made me angry, for later use.
Christopher O'Docharty:
I think this guy was a sorry jack ass who wasted part of his life doing nothing
and now he seems to be trying to make up for something. Someone has given him
another chance to grow(probably God) to make for wrong doings?
Carlo Savino:
chris:
what poem did you read? i'm not sure that he wasted part of his life, it's
just that at time he was overcome by anger, or frustration, or the like.
something like this tempts us every once in a while. he's saying that even
though this occurs, we have a chance to right our wrongs, begin the begin, and
grow anew.
Melanie Elizabeth Oxley:
Higinio
Imagine however if you could immidiately get on with motivation instead of
becoming angry first. The energy spent on anger could be PRODUCTIVELY funneled
for progression.
Lorena Velasquez:
Life and death, happiness and sorrow are intertwined. Life comes back in cycles
like a flower. Everything you experience in life will help you grow as a
person. Your experiences fluctuate from good to bad, from happy to sad. It's
what you make of those experiences is what matters.
Higinio Maycotte:
M, If you look at it that way, I completely agree.
Lin Jean:
Overcoming grief is an experience in itself. Growing towards heaven is what we
must strive for.... to live a clean and blameless life... that is really
idealistic, but it is true. When we start to bend, as a flower shys away from
anger, it is because we have angered God by straying from this idealistic path.
BUT God is a forgiving and loving God... if we humble ourselves and confess,
we will be back on the road to growing straight and in the right path.
Jason Lands:
Life would be boring if you couldn't get angry. We'd be Smurfs or something if
we happy 24 hours a day.
Carlo Savino:
i'd be gargamel
Julie Lopez:
You made a good pooint Lorena.
Jason Lands:
ok who's smurfette
Melanie Elizabeth Oxley:
I think this poem is a vivid beautiful analogy for human existence. Just as
there are many different flowers, so are there many different people-all with
their own sort of beauty.........
Who's Azreal????
Christopher O'Docharty:
Well, this poem was not an assignment! So put that in your corn pipe! Anyway,
the point is that I read what you put down. I still say he wasted alot of time
with this excessive pride.
Melanie Elizabeth Oxley:
P.S. I'm Smurfette
Carlo Savino:
okay, now i'm popeye
Bun Sentoso:
Jason is right !!
If you always keep your anger in yourself, you'll kill someone for playing
smurf in class, :)
We sometimes need to get angry, that's what I'm tryuing to say.
Melanie Elizabeth Oxley:
Carlo, you are a freak
Lin Jean:
We do need to get angry. It is a good stress reliever. Otherwise, we would be
"frustrated."
|
Internal and Internet Links to George Herberts
Reputation and Influence.
|